Critical Analysis of A Journal Article on Mentoring

Introduction Tech-infused mentoring by Judy Corner proposes numerous benefits from online technologys application to a companys mentoring program. Unfortunately, her reasoning and procedures do not support her optimistic conclusions. Corner spends too much writing space simply talking about the benefits of mentoring and generally referring to the benefits of online technology without giving nuts-and-bolts implementation procedures. The result is a professional journal article that is really a fluff piece. Body Summary of Main Points The selected article is Tech-infused mentoring by Judy Corner (Corner, June 2012). The main points of her article are that web technology can enhance mentoring by: finding a sufficient group of eligible participants for the mentoring program; finding the optimum mentor-mentee relationships from the pool of individuals in the program; guaranteeing that everyone involved in the mentoring program receives uniform information about the mentoring program; developing methods to keep mentors and mentees in touch; following, assessing and illustrating the achievements of the mentoring program; constructing an efficient case and plan for a companys mentoring program. Explanation of Whether or Not the Article Supports the Above Concept(s) as Presented in the Text The article supports the above concepts very generally but seems to replace specifics with quite a bit of pro-mentoring filler. The author begins by giving her definition ofShow MoreRelated Quantitative and Qualitative Article Analysis Essay1550 Words   |  7 Pagesthis paper I will analyze two articles, one is quantitative and the other is qualitative. I will describe the quantitative methods used including the research question addressed, the hypothesis, and variables. I will identify the population and sample. I will discuss the reliability and validity of the instruments used. I will then discuss the design of the article and how the findings were analyzed. For the qualitative article, I will identify the design of the article, the methods used and the strategiesRead MoreExpanding Leadership Diversity Through Formal Mentoring Programs1184 Words   |  5 Pagesleadership diversity through formal mentoring programs. Journal of Leadership Studies, 3(1), 47-60. To attract and retain people, it is essential that organizations design and successfully implement pro- grams and processes that develop people and nurture their talents. For those who aspire to a leader- ship role, the opportunity to engage in mentoring relationships with senior-level leaders is a powerful way to accelerate growth. In the majority of informal mentoring relationships, mentors and protà ©gà ©sRead MoreStudent-Teacher Relationships in Teacher Program Education s629 Words   |  3 Pagesmay not think about the use of the dictionary until she is asked about when to use it. The mentoring interactions portray habitual classroom situations that help thinking over particular Student Teachers’ performance (Clarke, 2001) eliciting, as a consequence, tacit knowledge that is only in the expert teacher’ mind. These genuine interactions between an expert teacher and a student teacher triggers critical reflection processes on teaching experiences and invites to fu rther think of what can be doneRead MoreData Evaluation with CARS Checklist: Factors That Affect Student Success in Nursing School1762 Words   |  7 PagesDunham, M. (2011). Predicting NCLEX-RN success in a diverse student population. Journal of Nursing Education, 50(5), 261-267. Bosch, P.C., Doshier, S.A., Gess-Newsome, J. (2012). Bilingual nurse education program: Applicant characteristics that predict success. Nursing Education Perspectives, 33(2), 90-95. Bronner, M. (1982). Bridges or barriers to success: The nature of the student experiences in nursing. Journal of Nursing Education, 21(7), 38-41. Carrick, J.A. (2011). Student achievementRead MoreDiversity For Success Of The Company1036 Words   |  5 PagesThe article was authored in 2013 by Barak, who is a knowledgeable and experienced professor, with an experience in social work and business. The book provides information on how to ensure there is inclusiveness in the workplace. The author reveals that management has to ensure it successfully handles diversity in the workforce. The author argues that in the current workforce, which is diverse, the challenge is exclusion. The book has compiled extensive current information on social policy trendsRead MoreThe Issues Of Diversity For Success Of The Company1037 Words   |  5 PagesThe article was written in 2013 by Barak, who is a knowledgeable and experienced professor, with an experience in social work and business. The book provides information on how to ensure there is inclusiveness in the workplace. The author reveals that management has to ensure it successfully handle s diversity in the workforce. The author argues that in the current workforce, which is diverse, the challenge is exclusion. The book compiles extensive current information on social policy trends, legislativeRead MorePracticum Evaluation: Orlando Childrens Clinic1821 Words   |  7 PagesPracticum Evaluation Summary Paper Name Professor Institution Course Date Introduction The analysis of the HCAHPS scores in relation to the medication communication reflects on the succession planning that involves managers and staffing. This is with the incorporation of a clarified vision with a strategic plan (Buerhaus, 2000). The succession planning for the respective key personnel is significant in business strategy to assist the healthcare organization in handling effectively its futureRead MoreCareer Satisfaction And Employee Retention For Novice Nursing Staff Essay1861 Words   |  8 PagesThe aim of this concept analysis will be to gain a broader understanding about the concept mentoring and how it is linked to employee satisfaction and employee retention to novice nursing staff. In an article from the Oklahoma Nurse journal it is mentioned that mentor programs and mentorship allows for continued growth for novice staff (Davis and Maisano, 2016). Dr. Benner s theory of Novice to Expert provides support that a novice to expert relationship occurs in a mentoring relationship; this relationshipRead MoreEffective Leadership Skills Among Tutors1610 Words   |  7 Pagesleadership skills among tutors in order to promote student learning through quality instruction. As mentioned in the previous chapter, this realization is significant for many reasons. As such, this chapter reinforces the research question through a critical analysis of the existing literature with the aim of coming up with a different line of thought. As such, the study could offer a new dimension of leadership perception that is appropriate in fostering student learning in the modern and changing schoolRead MoreExploring Beginning Teachers Perceptions On Formal Mentoring Programs2732 Words   |  11 PagesExploring Beginning Teachers’ Perceptions on Formal Mentoring Programs in Elementary Schools Introduction Central Phenomenon The risk of losing beginning teachers has been an issue in the United States for a long time. An immense amount of research has been conducted exploring why beginning teachers are leaving the profession. Fantilli and McDougall’s (2009) pointed out that beginning teachers have the same responsibilities and requirements as veteran teachers, but in addition to these factors